HOME HISTORY ARTICLES BUYOUT INTERVIEWS SHOP VIDEOS GAME FAQ SEARCH PRESS & CONTACT
  • HOME
  • HISTORY
  • ARTICLES
  • INTERVIEWS
  • BUYOUT
I Love Marmite
  • VIDEOS
  • FAQ
  • SEARCH
  • SHOP
  • PRESS & CONTACT
Spreading Marmite Love since 2000
  1. Home
  2. Articles
  3. Every Marmite limited edition, ranked from worst to best
Oct 20 2026 Post Icon

Every Marmite limited edition, ranked from worst to best

By: Seamus Waldron Published: 20 October 2026
Every Marmite limited edition, ranked from worst to best

Marmite runs a limited edition roughly as often as most brands change their font, and the hit rate is better than you would expect from a company messing about with a recipe that already works.

Ranking them is a slightly absurd exercise, which is why I’ve wanted to do it for a while. The criteria, such as they are: did it taste good, did it deserve to exist, and did anyone still care a year later. Some of these fail all three and I’ve kept them in anyway, because the failures are more interesting than the safe ones.

Worst to best.

10. Marmite Gold (2012). A gold jar for Christmas 2012, three hundred thousand of them, timed for the brand’s 110th anniversary in a year that also had the Olympics and the Diamond Jubilee in it.

The flecks in it were not gold. They were gold-coloured, and I knew that at the time, because I was working on the campaign that put this jar onto the Oxford Street Christmas lights. A good deal of the coverage said edible gold leaf, some of it still does, and our own post from 2012 repeated the press release along with everybody else. That one is on me and I will go back and fix it.

It tasted exactly like standard Marmite, because gold-coloured flecks have no flavour either. So the entire proposition was a jar of Marmite that cost more and looked better under a lamp. A stunt, and it knew it, which is why it is bottom of this list rather than absent from it.

9. Marmite Cherry Truffles. Chocolate and Marmite is the collaboration everyone suggests and nobody enjoys. The sweet-savoury thing works when the savoury is a background note; here it’s a foreground argument. We covered these at the time with more enthusiasm than I can currently summon.

8. The Marston’s Pedigree edition. Marmite made with the yeast from a specific beer, which is at least conceptually honest given the entire product is a brewing by-product. It came with a cricket tie-in. The trouble is that the difference is genuinely hard to detect unless you have both jars open at once, which almost nobody did.

7. Summer of Love. A jar with a nice label. Packaging-only editions are fine, and this one looked good, but it’s competing here against products that actually changed what was inside.

6. Ma’amite, twice (2012 and 2022). The Diamond and Platinum Jubilee jars, the first and the second. Same joke both times, and it’s a good joke, helped enormously by being one letter’s work. Packaging again, but a pun this economical earns its place.

5. M&S Marmite caramel. A Christmas caramel sauce, sold with the word “swalty”, which should have ended the meeting. The product itself is unexpectedly good on ice cream, and I say that as someone who went in wanting to dislike it.

4. The Elton John jars (2022 to 2025). Four jars over four years for the Elton John AIDS Foundation, ending with the I’m Still Standing design and a million pounds raised regardless of sales. Ranked here rather than higher because the contents never changed. Ranked this high because a limited edition that shifts a million pounds to an AIDS charity is doing more than selling jars.

3. Marmite XO (2010). Extra old, aged longer, noticeably stronger and deeper than standard. The jar was chosen by public vote and the Marmarati got at it first. This is the one the serious eaters still talk about, and the one I would most like back permanently.

2. Marmite Peanut Butter (2019, axed, returned 2025). The rare limited edition good enough that killing it caused a genuine complaint campaign, and good enough that it came back. Peanut butter and Marmite is a pairing that sounds wrong and is immediately obvious the moment you taste it: fat, salt, savoury depth, all pointing the same way.

1. Marmite Dynamite (2021). Chilli Marmite, Sainsbury’s exclusive, £3.99 for 250g, six months only. It came from people mixing chilli into their Marmite on social media and the brand deciding to just make the thing customers had already invented. It went on to generate 194 million impressions and £650,000 in earned media, and sold five times more jars than any previous limited edition, making it comfortably the most successful they have run. The full story is here. It also happens to be delicious, which helps.

The honourable mention

WeMite, from summer 2026, isn’t on the list because the recipe never changed. But renaming the entire brand and sizing the jars by how far you thought England would get is a better idea than half the entries above, and it had actual risk attached in a way that a new label doesn’t.

What the ranking tells you

The pattern isn’t subtle: the editions that changed what is in the jar outrank the ones that changed the label, with the single exception of the Elton John run, which bought its way up the table by raising a million pounds.

The other pattern is that Marmite is at its best when it stops trying to be sweet. Dynamite, XO and peanut butter all push in the direction the product already goes. The chocolate and the caramel are swimming against it, and only the caramel gets away with it.

What was the most successful Marmite limited edition?

Marmite Dynamite, the chilli variant launched in February 2021 as a Sainsbury’s exclusive at £3.99 for 250g. It generated 194 million impressions and £650,000 in earned media, and sold five times more jars than any previous limited edition, making it the brand’s most successful special edition to date.

What Marmite limited editions have there been?

The significant ones include Marmite XO (2010), Marmite Gold (2010), the Marston’s Pedigree beer edition, Ma’amite for the 2012 Diamond Jubilee and again for the 2022 Platinum Jubilee, Marmite Peanut Butter (2019, discontinued and reinstated in 2025), Marmite Dynamite chilli (2021), Marmite Truffle (2022), four Elton John AIDS Foundation jars between 2022 and 2025, an M&S Marmite caramel sauce, and the WeMite World Cup rebrand in 2026.

Tags: marmitelimitededitionrankeddynamitexogoldguinnesspeanutbuttermaamiteeltonjohn
Categories: Modern Era (1990-2025) , Limited Editions & Specials , Products & Varieties

Related Articles

  • WeMite: Marmite bet on England and picked the middle jar

    WeMite: Marmite bet on England and picked the middle jar

    Jul 16, 2026
  • Elton's last Marmite jar, and a million quid for the AIDS Foundation

    Elton's last Marmite jar, and a million quid for the AIDS Foundation

    Dec 5, 2025
  • Marmite Peanut Butter is back, nine months after Unilever killed it

    Marmite Peanut Butter is back, nine months after Unilever killed it

    Jun 19, 2025
  • Marmite Dynamite: the chilli jar that went off in 2021

    Marmite Dynamite: the chilli jar that went off in 2021

    Feb 7, 2021
  • Marmite Gold: the 2012 limited edition that was not actually gold

    Sep 9, 2012
  • Marmite XO

    Feb 22, 2010
Love Marmite Marmite Hate It The Marmite Mnemonicon Interviews The McCormick Buyout: all our coverage The Marmite A-List Marmite Myths Marmite Facts: things you didn't know The Marmite Shop Marmite Game: Tea Break

About I Love Marmite

Your comprehensive guide to Britain's most iconic yeast extract spread. Explore 200+ articles covering Marmite's rich history, cultural impact, recipes, news and everything about the spread you either love or hate.

Est. 2000 - Celebrating Marmite since 1902

Explore

  • Home
  • All Articles
  • Marmite History
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Useful Links
  • Contact Us

Popular Topics

  • Marmite History
  • Recipes
  • Latest News
  • British Culture
  • Nutrition & Health
  • Product Varieties

Article Archives

  • 2025 Articles
  • 2024 Articles
  • View All Articles
© 2000-2025 Seamus Waldron. All rights reserved.
I Love Marmite - The Ultimate Marmite Resource | Celebrating Britain's Most Divisive Spread